clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

In MLS, Picking up Cards isn't a Bad Thing

Despite Oswaldo Minda's Wondolowski-esque 13 yellow cards, Chivas USA actually finished 2012 as one of the least penalized teams in MLS.

Minda: Carried the torch for Chivas USA in the yellow card department.
Minda: Carried the torch for Chivas USA in the yellow card department.

Let's say you wanted to create a table to rank teams based solely on a team's accumulation of cards. There's already a measurement of this. It's called "Fairness Points" and it's a basic, if overly simplified, method to discern the league's more, ahem, "undisciplined" clubs.

Points are awarded as:

* yellow cards as one point

* second yellow as three points

* reds as five points

Using this metric, Chivas finished 2012 fourth in the so-called "Fairness Points" table with a score 53, 13 points (or one Oswaldo Minda) behind the Houston Dynamo with 40.

Interestingly, besides Houston, the remaining top five teams (the Colorado Rapids, New England Revolution, Chivas USA, and Toronto FC) share a common, unifying thread: they were all terrible in 2012.

Meanwhile, the so-called "losers", at the bottom of the table all made the playoffs: the Vancouver Whitecaps (81), Real Salt Lake (79) and the San Jose Earthquakes (77).

This trend is present in Chivas USA's own history. Take a look at the table below and note how the squad's Fairness Points fluctuate between playoff and non-playoff years.

Year Rank Games Played Table Points Fairness Points FP/Match Yellow Cards 2nd Yellow Red Cards Sent Off
2012 4 34 30 54 1.56 53 0 1 0*
2011 7 34 36 65 1.91 49 2 2 4
2010 6 30 28 57 1.9 47 0 2 2
2009 14 30 45 88 2.93 59 3 4 7
2008 13 30 43 87 2.9 61 2 4 6
2007 10 30 53 81 2.7 61 0 4 4

*I guess they didn't consider James Riley's dissent a "send off" because it came at the end of the game? (Ed: That matter has still never been explained by the league).

Indeed Chivas USA's fortunes (i.e. Table Points column) trends upwards when their rank on the Fairness Table recedes:


Back to 2012, Chivas actually accumulated more cautions than their opponents did: 56* to 47.

*I'm counting the US Open Cup matches here

The data is really inconclusive about "why" this phenomena exists. For instance, the Goats had four yellow cards in their win in Utah over RSL which really skewed the results.

But I'm going to take a crack at this: when the team is aggressive and attacking both on offense and defense they tend to play a better, more focused brand of football. However, if you are timid and nervously looking at the sidelines for instructions, that intensity and drive won't be there. After all the four teams that aren't Houston all had new coaches and new systems in place in 2012.

I always got the impression that Robin Fraser is a really smart guy but he tried giving the team too many instructions. Instead of playing soccer, they were busy processing like an overloaded computer. All of which may explain why he was so quick to use veterans even though the RSL model he preached emphasized a core group of young players who grew together through the same system.

For 2013, the lesson is that Chivas need players who get stuck in, who draw cards more often, and who aren't afraid to play on the edge of smart and dirty. To put it simply, they need a badass (or a few badasses).

What do you think? Leave a comment below!